Low Key Tiki

Nestled conveniently along the waterfront in St James City, Low Key Tiki is a spirited restaurant and bar that perfectly captures the laid-back island vibe of Pine Island. This vibrant local hotspot specializes in a fresh, flavorful blend of coastal and comfort cuisine, making it an irresistible destination for anyone craving bold tastes in a relaxed setting.

The menu at Low Key Tiki is an enticing showcase of island-inspired dishes fused with classic American favorites. Guests rave about the crunchy, golden Zucchini Fries and the irresistible Blackened Fish Tacos, where the perfectly seasoned, flaky fish melds beautifully with fresh toppings wrapped in a warm tortilla. Seafood lovers can indulge in the Coconut Shrimp, which boasts a delicate, sweet crunch balanced by tangy dipping sauces, or savor the Fish Bites—bite-sized morsels that deliver a burst of ocean-fresh flavor in every mouthful. For those who crave something heartier, the Tiki BBQ Chicken Sandwich offers tender smoked chicken laced with smoky-sweet barbecue sauce, while the Hawaiian Burger provides a juicy, tropical twist on classic burger fare.

The Stuff-On-A-Stick selections add a fun, shareable element to the menu, with options like the Beef Tenderloin skewers and the decadent Scallops wrapped in Bacon that pair perfectly with a cold drink. Speaking of drinks, Low Key Tiki offers a curated list of cold beers, including Guinness on tap, crisp wines like Barefoot Merlot and Chardonnay, and a variety of refreshing ciders—ideal companions for a warm Florida day.

Low Key Tiki’s atmosphere is where the magic truly unfolds. With its prime waterfront location flanked by cozy marinas, diners can enjoy their meal while watching boats gently drift by or wildlife like dolphins and eagles glide overhead. The restaurant’s modest, intimate seating encourages a friendly, community-centric vibe where locals and visitors mingle effortlessly. Several reviewers note the attentive, personable service and the lively energy created by regular live music performances, making every visit feel like a mini island celebration.

Whether you are stopping in for a quick lunch of loaded homemade chips and a refreshing beer or settling in for an evening with succulent fried shrimp po-boys and the sweet sounds of live guitar, Low Key Tiki promises an unbeatable combination of great food, drink, and waterside relaxation. It’s no surprise that regulars like M Sirnik and Michelle Ford consider it a treasured local hangout—this is truly a place to unwind, savor bold flavors, and soak in the charm of island life.